10 Signs Your Website Is Costing You Customers (And What to Do About It)

Your website should be your hardest-working salesperson.
It should attract the right people, tell your story clearly, and move visitors toward action.

But for a lot of brands, it’s doing the opposite.

It’s slowing things down. Creating friction. Confusing people. And quietly costing you customers every single day.

If your site isn’t pulling its weight, here are ten signs it might be working against you and what to do about each one.

‍

1. People Are Visiting… But Not Converting

You’re getting traffic, but no form fills, no demo requests, no sales.

That’s a conversion problem, not a traffic problem.

What to do:
Audit your homepage and key landing pages. Make sure:

• Your value proposition is clear above the fold
• Your CTA is obvious and compelling
• Your messaging is focused on your customer’s problem, not just your services
  
  

‍

2. Your Site Looks Fine… But Feels Forgettable

If your website could belong to literally anyone in your industry, that’s a problem.

Design isn’t just about looking good. It’s about being recognizable, memorable, and emotionally aligned with your brand.

What to do:
Revisit your brand expression. Does your site actually reflect your personality, voice, and positioning? Or is it just “nice”?

‍

3. It’s Slow (Especially on Mobile)

If your site takes more than a few seconds to load, people leave. Period.

What to do:
Optimize images, streamline code, reduce unnecessary scripts, and test your mobile speed specifically. Performance is part of design now.

‍

4. Mobile Feels Like an Afterthought

More than half of your visitors are probably on their phones. If your mobile experience is clunky, cramped, or hard to navigate, you’re losing them.

What to do:
Adopt a mobile-first mindset. Design for thumbs, not cursors.

‍

5. It Talks About You More Than Your Customer

If your copy is all “we” and not enough “you,” visitors won’t feel seen.

What to do:
Reframe your messaging around:

• Your customer’s goals
• Their pain points
• Their desired outcomes
  
  

Your brand still matters. But connection comes first.

‍

6. There’s No Clear Next Step

If someone lands on your site and doesn’t know what to do next, they’ll do nothing.

What to do:
Every page should guide users toward a specific action. Not ten options. One.

‍

7. Your Navigation Is Overwhelming

If people can’t quickly find what they’re looking for, they won’t try very hard.

What to do:
Simplify. Fewer menu items. Clear labels. Logical structure.

‍

8. Your Visuals Don’t Match Your Quality

If your business is high-end, thoughtful, or premium, but your site feels cheap, generic, or outdated, there’s a disconnect.

And people feel that.

What to do:
Invest in visuals that actually represent the experience of working with you.

‍

9. You Haven’t Touched It in Years

Your business has evolved. Your audience has evolved. Your website should evolve too.

If your site is frozen in time, it’s probably not aligned with where you are now.

What to do:
Treat your website like a living asset, not a one-and-done project.

‍

10. It’s Not Helping Your Sales or Marketing Team

If your sales team avoids sending people to your site, or your marketing team is constantly working around it, that’s a red flag.

What to do:
Your website should support your growth engine, not slow it down.

‍

Final Thought

Your website isn’t just a design project. It’s a business tool.

When it’s working well, it builds trust, creates clarity, and turns interest into action.
When it’s not, it quietly leaks opportunity.

The good news? All of this is fixable.

And when you fix it intentionally, your website becomes one of the most powerful growth tools you have.

If you’re wondering whether your site is helping or hurting your growth, let’s take a look together.
We design websites that are built to perform, not just exist.